Main Office

Susie Vertoske'88
Office Manager
607.734.2267 x3012


Michael Cinquanti

Director of Technology


Email Questions or Concerns to:
607.734.2267 x111

Advancement & Alumni Relations

Katie Lilley '97

Director of Advancement & Alumni Relations
 607-734-2267 Ext 325

Theresa Tobey
Notre Dame Advancement & Business Office Associate
607.734.2267 x329

Business Office

Naomi Kinsman
Finance Office Manager
607.734.2267 x318

Tracy Mustico 
Business Manager
607.734.2267 x305


Max Young
Athletic Manager

Public Relations

Michelle Barkley
Director of Public Relations and Marketing
607.734.2267 x321​


Mina Barron

School Counselor

Guidance Department Chair
607.734.2267 x311

Brett Moore

Director of Enrollment

Academic Coordinator Gr. 7 & 8
607-734-2267​ x312

Brittany Tyler
Guidance Registrar and Student Data Management Director
607.734.2267 x310​

Campus Ministry

Marie McCaig
Campus Minister
607.734.2267 x319​

Theatre Department

Cody Riker
Performing Arts Department Chair/Teacher

Food Services

Email Questions or Concerns to:
607.734.2267 x314​

Sandra Simpson

Director of Food Services

Kitchen Staff:

Valerie White
Lytessia McKay​

Maintenance & Custodial  


John Strauss 


Building & Grounds

Brian Minchin 
Superintendent of Building & Grounds

  • Facebook
(607) 734-2267
1400 Maple Avenue Elmira, NY 14904

© 2020 Notre Dame High School  | A Ministry of the Sisters of Mercy | Proudly created by Parisi Solutions