Main Office

Susie Vertoske'88
Office Manager
607.734.2267 x3012


Michael Cinquanti

Director of Technology


Email Questions or Concerns to:
607.734.2267 x111

Advancement & Alumni Relations

Katie Lilley '97

Director of Advancement & Alumni Relations
 607-734-2267 Ext 325

Theresa Tobey
Notre Dame Advancement & Business Office Associate
607.734.2267 x329

Business Office

Robert McNamara ('65)
Finance Office Manager
607.734.2267 x322​

Tracy Mustico 
Business Manager
607.734.2267 x305


Michael Johnston
Interim Athletic Director
607.734.2267 x304

Public Relations

Michelle Barkley
Director of Public Relations and Marketing
607.734.2267 x321​


Karen Jennings
Director Grade 7 & 8
Academic Advisor Gr. 9
607.734.2267 x312​

Brett Moore
Guidance Coordinator
607-734-2267​ x319


Mina Barron, Department Chair 
Counselor, Academic Advisor Grades 10, 11, 12
607.734.2267 x311

Tina Shannon 
Guidance Registrar and Student Data Management Director
607.734.2267 x310​

Campus Ministry

Marie McCaig
Campus Minister
607.734.2267 x319​

Theatre Department

Cody Riker
Director of Theater

Food Services

Email Questions or Concerns to:
607.734.2267 x314​

Sandra Simpson

Director of Food Services

Kitchen Staff:

Valerie White
Lytessia McKay​

Maintenance & Custodial  


John Strauss 
​Roger Williams


Building & Grounds

Brian Minchin 
Superintendent of Building & Grounds

Micah Roush

  • Grey Facebook Icon
(607) 734-2267
1400 Maple Avenue Elmira, NY 14904

© 2018 Notre Dame High School  | A Ministry of the Sisters of Mercy | Proudly created by Parisi Solutions